Skip to content
The 51st State
ES / EN
The Tracker

What happens, kept apart from what it means

Fact

Car caravans call for María Corina Machado’s return

The fact
Car caravans in Caracas, Valencia, Maracaibo, and Mérida called for Machado’s safe return and for presidential elections.
What this changes for the question
People want change, but the system is still in control. The constitutional process has been exhausted: there is no law anymore, and the Constitution is a dead letter. Ordinary Venezuelans are bringing it back to life in the streets, where they are demanding that it be restored through free elections, with the diaspora taking part.
Sources
Al Jazeera (archived copy) · Infobae (EFE) (archived copy)
Fact

39 political prisoners released

The fact
After the second round of talks, the interim government freed 39 political prisoners, according to the NGO Justicia, Encuentro y Perdón.
What this changes for the question
Dialogue is the formula the government has always used to buy time. Every rupture has been quieted, lulled to sleep, and forgotten through endless talks that solve nothing.
Sources
Al Jazeera (archived copy) · Manila Times (archived copy)
Fact

Second round of talks between government and opposition ends

The fact
The delegations agreed on a commission of seven experts to evaluate the candidates for the new Supreme Tribunal of Justice, and on the unblocking of digital media outlets. The third round was set for mid-October.
What this changes for the question
Time is pressing, and this is part of the process. But there is a break in the constitutional order: the Assembly has not been chosen in free elections since 2015, and the interim presidency has already exceeded the 180 days set by Article 234 of the Constitution. That is why whatever comes out of this can only be considered temporary, until every branch of government has been fully relegitimized. Today everything is temporary and transitional.
Sources
Infobae (EFE) (archived copy) · ANSA Latina (archived copy)
Fact

At the UN, Delcy Rodríguez promises elections, with no date

The fact
In her first speech to the General Assembly, the interim president thanked Trump for the restoration of relations and promised elections without setting a date.
What this changes for the question
As always: promises with no date, endless dialogue, power and control unchanged.
Sources
AP (KPBS) (archived copy) · Al Jazeera (archived copy)
Fact

First meeting between Trump and Delcy Rodríguez

The fact
They met in New York during the UN General Assembly, with Marco Rubio and Scott Bessent present. They discussed energy, mining, security, and debt. It was the first direct meeting since Maduro’s capture.
Sources
ARA (archived copy) · A News (archived copy)
Fact

Machado fails to enter Venezuela

The fact
According to her party, María Corina Machado tried three times in 24 hours to return to the country from Panama, by air and by sea, without success.
What this changes for the question
Another example of the Venezuelan reality. People say Venezuela changed on January 3, but the essentials have not changed: Venezuelans are still under the control of the same system. The fall of the leader does not destroy the system; Chávez’s death did not end it either.
Sources
CBS News (archived copy) · UPI
Fact

House Democrats press for answers on the oil deal

The fact
Representatives Robert Garcia, Gregory Meeks, and Jared Huffman asked the State Department and the Justice Department for information on Alejandro Betancourt’s role in the deal.
What this changes for the question
In a democracy, participation and transparency always matter, all the more so with an interim government that Venezuelans did not elect and that is not in line with the Venezuelan Constitution.
Sources
Semafor (archived copy) · Rio Times (archived copy)
Fact

UN mission: the repressive apparatus remains intact

The fact
The Independent International Fact-Finding Mission concluded that, despite limited political changes, Venezuela’s repressive institutions remain intact.
What this changes for the question
This is the clearest reading of all: the system is stronger than its own leaders. Restoring democracy is not a matter of replacing one person; it means rebuilding the institutions and refounding the republic.
Sources
OHCHR (archived copy) · UPI
Fact

Poll: half of Venezuelans believe the U.S. will gain more from the oil deal

The fact
In the AtlasIntel poll for Bloomberg, 50.2% of Venezuelans surveyed believe the United States will benefit more. The deal is opposed by 37.6% and supported by 35.4%.
What this changes for the question
The deal has divided Venezuelan opinion: people do not know its full details, they do not know whether it is legal, and, above all, it is being handled by a temporary authority whose term has already run out (Article 234 of the Constitution).
Sources
El Espectador (archived copy) · Bloomberg
Fact

Chris Wright sets the deal in motion in Caracas

The fact
The U.S. energy secretary and Delcy Rodríguez put the deal into effect. Agreements were signed with Chevron, Eni, and GE Vernova. Rodríguez said there will be elections when Venezuela is prepared for them, without giving a date.
What this changes for the question
There is no date for the transition, and the path is not clear. That creates uncertainty and fear, and it leaves in control the system that has subjugated and expelled millions of Venezuelans.
Sources
El Tiempo (archived copy) · Infobae (archived copy)
Fact

The White House publishes the terms of the deal

The fact
The operator is North American Blue Energy Partners (NABEP), with concessions on 17 fields. The U.S. government will hold 35% of NABEP’s parent company. News outlets differ on the term of the concessions: 100 years or 25.
What this changes for the question
The deal is still unclear. The information is not fully public, especially the specific terms. That is why its constitutionality is in doubt from the outset: the deposits are inalienable (Article 12 of the Constitution), and no public-interest contract may be entered into with foreign states or official foreign entities without the approval of the National Assembly (Article 150). The doubts will remain until its real scope is known.
Sources
CNBC (archived copy) · World Oil (archived copy)
Fact

Trump announces an oil deal with Venezuela

The fact
On Truth Social, Trump announced a deal that, in his words, gives the United States majority control of some 65 billion barrels of proven reserves in 17 fields. Delcy Rodríguez welcomed it.
Sources
NPR (archived copy) · Al Jazeera (archived copy)
Fact

Rubio: the transition will take “months and weeks”

The fact
Marco Rubio said Venezuela’s transition will take “not years” but “months and weeks,” and described it in three phases: economic stabilization, political stabilization, and elections.
What this changes for the question
Marco Rubio is of Cuban descent: he learned at the family table what criminal regimes do to decent people. He is bilingual, and he is a man worthy of respect. He is defining the steps and giving time estimates because he understands the need. In his knowledge and his capacity to contribute to this process, he is comparable to María Corina Machado.
Sources
Newsweek (archived copy) · Jamaica Observer (AFP) (archived copy)
Fact

Trump again posts the map of Venezuela as the 51st state

The fact
On Truth Social, Donald Trump posted a map of Venezuela bearing the U.S. flag and the label “51st State.”
What this changes for the question
This is the question that gave rise to the book The 51st State, brought into the public arena by the most influential person there is. Trump does not handle it in the shadows: he puts it in plain view, and that allows it to be discussed freely.
Sources
Infobae (archived copy) · Diario Libre (archived copy)
Fact

María Corina Machado responds to the 51st-state idea on CNN

The fact
On Erin Burnett OutFront, Machado said Trump is sending a message to many people, and certainly to the regime.
What this changes for the question
María Corina Machado was flawless in her remarks. Will she be the first elected president of a free and democratic Venezuela? Will she be the first governor of the 51st State?
Sources
Efecto Cocuyo (archived copy) · El Tiempo (archived copy)
Fact

The White House shares the 51st-state map

The fact
The official White House account on X shared a map of Venezuela labeled as the 51st state. Gustavo Petro responded on X, opposing the idea.
What this changes for the question
The idea reaches the official White House account, and a leader sympathetic to the regime comes out against it. It is a signal that has to be read carefully.
Sources
MercoPress (archived copy) · El Nacional (archived copy)
Fact

Delcy Rodríguez rejects the idea in The Hague

The fact
Leaving the International Court of Justice hearing on the Essequibo, the interim president said: “That would never be contemplated.”
What this changes for the question
Venezuela’s Constitution establishes that its territory and its sovereignty cannot be renounced (Articles 1 and 13). Article 10 defines that territory as that of the Captaincy General of Venezuela, which includes the Essequibo.
Sources
La Nación (AFP) (archived copy) · NTN24 (archived copy)
Fact

Venezuela wins the World Baseball Classic, and Trump posts “STATEHOOD!!!”

The fact
Venezuela beat the United States 3–2 in the final in Miami, its first title in the tournament. Afterward, Trump posted “STATEHOOD!!!” on Truth Social; the day before, he had written “STATEHOOD, #51, ANYONE?”
What this changes for the question
Venezuela is a baseball powerhouse, and many Venezuelans play in the major leagues. The United States, through its president, does not say it lost: it says the 51st State won.
Sources
Al Jazeera (archived copy) · Forbes (archived copy)